Constitution Under Attack; Media Banned From Wildlife Refuge Being Affected By BP Gulf Oil SpillPostedby Alexander Higgins -
July 7, 2010 at 8:38 p
A
post over at treehugger.com points
us to yet another instance of the
US
Constitution being violated by those participating in the
BP Gulf Oil Spill coverup.
The media has been banned from entering the Bon Secour National
Wildlife Refuge in Alabama which is being affected by the BP Gulf Oil
Spill.
I have said it before and I will say it again, this is a direct
violation of the civil liberties that our Founding Fathers sacrificed
their blood to give us.
Specifically it violates the First Amendment of the US Constitution,
part of the Bill of Rights, which grants us the Freedom of Press and the
Freedom of Speech.
The latest violation is on top two other blatant violations of our
civil rights including a BP enforced NO-FLY ZONE over the BP Gulf Oil
Spill and restriction zone imposed by the Federal Government that
effectively bans the media from all access to boom, spill, clean up
operations and response vessels.
It simply can not be tolerated.
<blockquote>
Cameras Not Allowed in Alabama Wildlife RefugeIf that weren’t bad enough, the
Institute for Southern Studies reports that when John Wathen of the
Waterkeeper Alliance went to the Bon Secour National Wildlife Refuge we spoke with state
troopers guarding the entrance:
<blockquote>“Excuse me, sir, is there a rule against cameras down
there?” Wathen asks. “Some guy came out and told me I couldn’t be down
there taking pictures.”"The media’s not allowed to go down,” the trooper
answers. “As far as cameras and things down there, I don’t think
they’re allowed.”</blockquote>
This just reinforces the developing picture: Despite assurances to
the contrary by BP and all branches of the government, both state and
federal, working on this, no one is too keen on images of either the
clean up or the effects of the oil spill on ecosystems or wildlife
getting out that aren’t carefully stage managed. This is far more about
censoring what images get out there than safety, even if there are
safety concerns involved.
UPDATE: Photographer for ProPublica and PBS’ Frontline
Detained by PoliceThe
Committee to Protect
Journalists reports that photographer Lance Rosenfeld, on
assignment for
ProPublica and
Frontline was detained by police
near a BP refinery in Texas:
<blockquote>Shortly after arriving in town, Rosenfeld was confronted
by a BP security officer, local police, and a man who identified
himself as an agent of the Department of Homeland Security, according to
ProPublica. Police released the photographer after reviewing his
images and recording his date of birth and Social Security number. The
police officer then turned the information over to the BP security
guard according to ProPublica.
Cameras not allowed in Alabama wildlife refuge affectedby oil spill (video)</blockquote></blockquote>The latest video from the BP oil disaster by
Hurricane Creekkeeper John Wathen of Alabama shows the difficulties reporters and others face in trying
to document the effects of the catastrophe.
Footage posted to YouTube today finds Wathen at the entrance to the
Bon
Secour National Wildlife Refuge in coastal Alabama
speaking to one of the state troopers guarding the entrance.
“Excuse me, sir, is there a rule against cameras down there?” Wathen
asks. “Some guy came out and told me I couldn’t be down there taking
pictures.”
“The media’s not allowed to go down,” the trooper answers. “As far
as cameras and things down there, I don’t think they’re allowed.”
The incident comes amid mounting concerns over efforts to limit
documentation of the ongoing oil disaster.
Late last month, the Coast Guard
established 65-foot safety zones around protective boom and vessels actively responding to the spill in
Southeast Louisiana. The policy was reportedly a reaction to instances
where boom was vandalized or broken by non-response vessels getting too
close.
The Coast Guard initially established a safety zone of more than 300
feet but later reduced the distance. In order to get closer than 65
feet, media must get special permission from the Coast Guard captain of
the Port of New Orleans.
Violating the safety zone can result in felony charges and up to a
$40,000 civil penalty. However, a spokesperson for the BP Deepwater
Horizon Response insisted the distance was “insignificant” for
gathering images.
“In fact, these zones, which do not target the press, can and have
been opened for reporters as required,” Megan Moloney
said.
The New Orleans Times-Picayune
has reported that the rule could
make it difficult to photograph and document the impacts of oil on land
and wildlife.
In response to mounting concerns over barriers to press coverage of
the oil disaster, AFTRA — the union of broadcast journalists — has
begun
collecting stories of access denied:
Alabama
State Trooper says "No media allowed"
<object width="480" height="385"><param name="movie" value="https://www.youtube.com/v/o5OwawUlbys&hl=en_GB&fs=1?color1=0x402061&color2=0x9461ca"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="https://www.youtube.com/v/o5OwawUlbys&hl=en_GB&fs=1?color1=0x402061&color2=0x9461ca" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="480" height="385"></embed></object>
CNN has published an article on the situation assuring us that the
GulfCoast folks will fight for their rights and will not
tolerate the violation of their unalienable rights .
<blockquote>(CNN) — Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Our
forefathers penned those simple words into the Declaration of
Independence 234 years ago as a promise to every citizen of their
fledgling country. Today, millions of Americans living along the Gulf
Coast find those unalienable rights threatened.
I grew up on the Mississippi Gulf Coast. It was a place of pristine,
natural beauty. Miles of soft, sandy beaches. The gentle, warm waters of
the Mississippi Sound. The bays that cut inland to rivers and streams
lined with grassy marshes and bayous that served as nurseries for tiny
crabs, shrimp and all manner of fish and marine life.
This weekend, as the nation celebrated, the first black tar balls and
foul patties from the oil spill washed up on the beaches of my
hometown. Bay St. Louis was hosting its annual Crab Fest on Friday when
the quarter- to fist-size globs began rolling in. My brother called to
say he’d spotted some in front of the site of our former home on South
Beach Boulevard. It was sickening.
The people of the Gulf Coast are a hardy bunch. They already faced
the worst nature could dish out when Hurricane Katrina hit. And just as
they were getting back on their feet after years of heartache and
struggle, the worst man-made environmental disaster in U.S. history
smacks them back down.
That is what makes this such a difficult time for my family, friends
and neighbors on the Gulf Coast. Hurricane Katrina left them with a new
sense of vulnerability. Its scars are deep. And they are tired to the
bone.
But that doesn’t mean they won’t fight. It is a lesson BP executives
or anyone else who would underestimate them ignores at their peril. At
times of crisis, those in the claims division of corporate giants often
reason that residents who’ve lost everything will take anything. So they
offer shrimpers, oystermen and those who fish the Gulf Coast waters
pennies on the dollar for their losses.
…
A high school classmate messaged me on Facebook that her adult
daughter was coloring with her 5-year-old and drew some waves and a
bright sun in the sky. The child reached over and scribbled a yellow
blob over the water. When asked what it was, she said, “That’s the oil.”
Even the youngest see the place they love slipping away. Because it’s
not just those who ply their trade on the sea, or who house, feed or
entertain tourists, who stand to lose. People live on the Gulf Coast
because of the way of life there. They walk its beaches, sail and fish
its waters, and daily draw mental and physical sustenance from what it
offers. It is in their blood: a part of them.
How do you compensate them for its loss? My brother, an avid
recreational fisherman, was schooled in fishing the Gulf Coast waters at
my father’s knee. He has shared that love and respect for the water and
the abundant bounty it offers with his four children. Every week, he
e-mails me photos of them smiling broadly and holding their latest catch
of crabs, flounder or speckled trout. As the waters open for fishing
shrink to nothing, I know those photos and the smiles will stop.
BP promises it will make things right. Those I know and love on the
Gulf Coast want to believe that. I want to believe it. But history, back
to our nation’s founding days, teaches us the “small people” — as BP’s
chairman called Gulf Coast residents — regularly have to fight for life,
liberty and the pursuit of happiness against those who would take it
from them.
Over the Fourth of July weekend, I drew hope from a 1774 speech John
Adams delivered in Massachusetts before heading south as a delegate to
the first Continental Congress. “The meanest and lowest of the people
are by the unalterable indefeasible laws of God and nature as well
entitled to the benefit of the air to breathe, light to see, food to eat
and clothes to wear as the nobles or the king. That is liberty. And
liberty will reign in America.”</blockquote>That peice from CNN also makes reference
KindraArnesen who has turned whistle blower and exposed the BP Gulf Oil Spill
coverup.
If you haven’t read that post I highly encourage you to do so and
watch Kindra’s entire speech.
http://blog.alexanderhiggins.com/2010/07/07/constitution-attack-media-banned-wildlife-refuge-affected-bp-gulf-oil-spill//